MLB Draftkings Picks for May 9, 2025

Daily Player Picks

Updated Throughout the Day

Player expected costs and values are calculated every thirty minutes throughout the day.


Pitchers

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Tarik Skubal DET $11,500 25.99 2.26
Hunter Brown HOU $11,000 23.25 2.11
Luis Castillo SEA $8,400 17.37 2.07
Aaron Nola PHI $8,300 16.67 2.01

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Tarik Skubal DET $11,500 25.99 2.26
Tomoyuki Sugano BAL $7,000 14.87 2.12
Hunter Brown HOU $11,000 23.25 2.11
Luis Castillo SEA $8,400 17.37 2.07

Catcher

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Agustin Ramirez MIA $4,000 10.28 2.57
Ivan Herrera STL $4,100 9.74 2.37
Carson Kelly CHC $5,800 9.31 1.61
Cal Raleigh SEA $5,000 8.85 1.77

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Agustin Ramirez MIA $4,000 10.28 2.57
Rafael Marchan PHI $2,300 5.89 2.56
Gabriel Moreno ARI $2,900 7.03 2.42
Ivan Herrera STL $4,100 9.74 2.37

First Base

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Freddie Freeman LAD $6,100 11.03 1.81
Agustin Ramirez MIA $4,000 10.28 2.57
Ivan Herrera STL $4,100 9.74 2.37
Carson Kelly CHC $5,800 9.31 1.61

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Matt Gorski PIT $2,000 5.97 2.99
Rowdy Tellez SEA $2,500 7.39 2.96
Andrew Vaughn CWS $2,400 6.78 2.83
Agustin Ramirez MIA $4,000 10.28 2.57

Use our SFTB Plus optimizers to perfect your DFS roster. Include or Exclude players and teams, and see our 10 best rosters for every available slate.


Second Base

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Bryson Stott PHI $4,800 9.62 2.00
Gleyber Torres DET $5,300 9.14 1.72
Brice Turang MIL $4,700 8.89 1.89
Ketel Marte ARI $5,000 8.85 1.77

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Colt Keith DET $2,700 7.74 2.87
Brendan Rodgers HOU $2,800 6.35 2.27
Lenyn Sosa CWS $2,600 5.84 2.25
Adam Frazier PIT $2,900 6.49 2.24

Short Stop

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Bobby Witt Jr. KC $5,900 11.33 1.92
Francisco Lindor NYM $5,500 10.60 1.93
Zach Neto LAA $4,700 10.59 2.25
Trea Turner PHI $5,200 10.31 1.98

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Masyn Winn STL $3,500 9.12 2.61
Trey Sweeney DET $2,900 7.25 2.50
Willy Adames SF $3,900 9.38 2.40
Zach Neto LAA $4,700 10.59 2.25

Use our SFTB Plus optimizers to perfect your DFS roster. Include or Exclude players and teams, and see our 10 best rosters for every available slate.


Third Base

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Manny Machado SD $5,700 10.20 1.79
Rafael Devers BOS $4,800 10.12 2.11
Matt Chapman SF $4,400 9.71 2.21
Jose Ramirez CLE $5,100 9.40 1.84

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Emmanuel Rivera BAL $2,500 7.05 2.82
Josh Rojas CWS $2,200 6.11 2.78
Ernie Clement TOR $2,200 5.95 2.71
Alec Bohm PHI $3,300 7.32 2.22

Outfield

Best Rating

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Aaron Judge NYY $6,400 12.79 2.00
Byron Buxton MIN $5,300 11.44 2.16
Fernando Tatis Jr. SD $6,500 11.41 1.76
Oneil Cruz PIT $6,000 11.34 1.89
Jackson Merrill SD $6,000 11.26 1.88
Corbin Carroll ARI $5,900 10.93 1.85
Brent Rooker ATH $5,400 10.50 1.94
Kyle Tucker CHC $6,200 10.28 1.66

Best Values

Name Team Cost Expected Value
Sam Haggerty TEX $2,000 8.11 4.05
Rece Hinds CIN $3,000 10.25 3.42
Stuart Fairchild ATL $2,000 6.63 3.32
Jonatan Clase TOR $2,000 5.92 2.96
Ramon Laureano BAL $2,600 7.64 2.94
James Outman LAD $2,100 6.00 2.86
Dane Myers MIA $3,100 8.45 2.72
Justyn-Henry Malloy DET $3,000 7.91 2.64

Picks are based on historical performance and match-up. Picks are updated regularly, but we advise that you keep up to date on late-day roster moves and injuries – those are not taken into consideration. Sports from the Basement provides no warranty on these suggestions and readers should make picks at their own risk. Sample lineups are provided as thought-starters, and are not intended for direct use.